At 16:59 19/05/2015, Eliot Lear wrote:
I would state it differently: I am all for the names community to
have choices, but let's agree that there are ramifications for the
other communities, and those ramifications should be addressed and
not swept under the rug.
Dear Eliot,
I know this is the case because I am the one posing the question that
no one wants to consider it (this is also part of my game :-) ).
However, there also are ramifications for other RFC 6852 (corporate,
national, Libre) "global communities" and for their own "ICANN"s and "IANA"s.
Those ramifications should be addressed and not swept under the
supposed troll's rug. You were gallant enough to question the PTI
artificial issue that ICANN uses for the few of the affinity group
(in toto, only 68 different people were related to the IANAPLAN
mailing list) to focus on it instead of discussing the Google,
Amazon, Facebook, VeriSign, China, Russia, Libre, Europe,
Lichtenstein, etc. strategies' technical implications and the MYCANN-Plug-in.
The time has come to consider the real issue: how is the catenet to
transition from NTIA's multilateralism to a MULTICANN
multistakeholderism? I am going on a vacation. When I am back, I will
forward my appeal to the IAB, asking for an IETF WG/MULTICANN to be
chartered. If this is denied, I will ask for a non-WG
[email protected] mailing list. If I am denied that, I will appeal
it (NB! This mail respects the RFC 2026 appeal preparation procedure
requiring the relevant ADs to be informed). If still denied, I will
be obliged to accept that on Jan 8, 2015 Jari Arkko actually forked
the IETF over to the US/IETF, when stating "The NTIA must then
consider and approve the proposal. Finally, it must be implemented."
A "MUST" not ultimately resulting from a Global IETF rough consensus
but rather from a local political decision. The democratic internet
legend will definitely be gone with the wind. I am afraid that this
might be to everyone's detriment.
Take care and thank you for all your hard work on this issue.
jfc
_______________________________________________
comptoir mailing list
[email protected]
http://cafedu.com/mailman/listinfo/comptoir_cafedu.com
