commits  

Messages by Date

• 2025/07/02 svn commit: r1090575 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/07/02 svn commit: r1090575 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/07/02 svn commit: r1090575 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/07/01 svn commit: r1090562 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/07/01 svn commit: r1090562 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/07/01 svn commit: r1090562 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/30 svn commit: r1090556 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/30 svn commit: r1090556 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/30 svn commit: r1090556 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/29 svn commit: r1090552 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/29 svn commit: r1090552 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/29 svn commit: r1090552 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/28 svn commit: r1090548 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/28 svn commit: r1090548 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/28 svn commit: r1090548 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/27 svn commit: r1090529 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/27 svn commit: r1090529 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/27 svn commit: r1090529 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/26 svn commit: r1090525 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/26 svn commit: r1090525 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/26 svn commit: r1090525 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/25 svn commit: r1090515 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/25 svn commit: r1090515 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/25 svn commit: r1090515 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/24 svn commit: r1090510 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/24 svn commit: r1090510 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/24 svn commit: r1090510 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/23 (tapestry-5) branch feature/requirejs-less created (now 96eb4e719) thiagohp
• 2025/06/23 svn commit: r1090504 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/23 svn commit: r1090504 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/23 svn commit: r1090504 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/22 svn commit: r1090495 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/22 svn commit: r1090495 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/22 svn commit: r1090495 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/21 svn commit: r1090488 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/21 svn commit: r1090488 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/21 svn commit: r1090488 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/20 svn commit: r1090479 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/20 svn commit: r1090479 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/20 svn commit: r1090479 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/19 svn commit: r1090458 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/19 svn commit: r1090458 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/19 svn commit: r1090458 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/18 svn commit: r1090439 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/18 svn commit: r1090439 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/18 svn commit: r1090439 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/18 [jira] [Updated] (TAP5-2810) Support for running Tapestry without Require.js Thiago Henrique De Paula Figueiredo (Jira)
• 2025/06/18 [jira] [Updated] (TAP5-2810) Support for running Tapestry without Require.js Thiago Henrique De Paula Figueiredo (Jira)
• 2025/06/18 [jira] [Assigned] (TAP5-2810) Support for running Tapestry without Require.js Thiago Henrique De Paula Figueiredo (Jira)
• 2025/06/18 [jira] [Created] (TAP5-2810) Support for running Tapestry without Require.js Thiago Henrique De Paula Figueiredo (Jira)
• 2025/06/17 svn commit: r1090430 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/17 svn commit: r1090430 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/17 svn commit: r1090430 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/16 svn commit: r1090418 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/16 svn commit: r1090418 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/16 svn commit: r1090418 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/16 [jira] [Closed] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript Thiago Henrique De Paula Figueiredo (Jira)
• 2025/06/15 svn commit: r1090402 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/15 svn commit: r1090402 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/15 svn commit: r1090402 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) 03/03: TAP5-2809: removed singluar test that relied on a Groovy bug benw
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) 02/03: TAP5-2809: Update commons libs to latest versions benw
• 2025/06/15 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/15 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/15 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) branch gradle-improvements updated (900de2e42 -> c1f307648) benw
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) 01/03: TAP5-2809: Fix groovy test benw
• 2025/06/15 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) branch gradle-improvements updated: TAP5-2809: Groovy 3.0.13 -> 4.0.27 benw
• 2025/06/15 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/15 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/15 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/15 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) 01/04: TAP5-2809: split build.gradle further, modernize benw
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) branch gradle-improvements updated (ebb298eea -> a8f7bdb12) benw
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) 02/04: TAP5-2809: Gradle 8.5 -> 8.14.2 benw
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) 04/04: TAP5-2809: fix deprecations, cleanup benw
• 2025/06/15 (tapestry-5) 03/04: TAP5-2809: split build.gradle further, modernize benw
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2803) Add support for JavaScript/ECMAScript 6 modules Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2803) Add support for JavaScript/ECMAScript 6 modules Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2803) Add support for JavaScript/ECMAScript 6 modules Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2803) Add support for JavaScript/ECMAScript 6 modules Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2803) Add support for JavaScript/ECMAScript 6 modules ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 (tapestry-5) branch javax updated: TAP5-2803: Fixing bad service configuration contribution thiagohp
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2803) Add support for JavaScript/ECMAScript 6 modules ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 (tapestry-5) branch master updated: TAP5-2803: Fixing bad service configuration contribution thiagohp
• 2025/06/14 svn commit: r1090396 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/14 svn commit: r1090396 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/14 svn commit: r1090396 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2806) Upgrade Antlr 3 to 4 Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 (tapestry-5) branch javax updated: TAP5-2804: fixing bad merge on tapestry-core/build.gradle thiagohp
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2783) Hibernate module initialization fails when entities with compound ids exist Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2779) Tapestry 5.8.3 to 5.8.7 issues caused by the multiple classloader feature Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2772) ClassCastException happening in some cases in production mode Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2771) Upgrade to Spock 2.3 Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2789) Create Maven configuration tool to assist with suffixed artifacts Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2758) Constructor/Builder injection should support @Symbol for List/Collection/Map even without @Inject Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2780) JSONObject does not conform to equals/hashCode contract Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2791) CssCompressor for CSS files produces wrong minification for url() function, at least with data URLs Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2787) Infinite loop in PageSourceImpl with multiple classloader mode on Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2741) Update to Jakarta EE 9 Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2785) Change build so it generates separate artifacts for jakarta- and javax-based subprojects Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2794) Upgrade away from vulnerable commons-io and commons-fileupload dependencies Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2800) Stylesheets not imported when @Import also imports a library when in multiple classloader mode Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2792) POST with body throws exception Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2786) Attempt to override final method in subclass when in multiple classloader mode Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2775) ClassNotFoundException when in production mode and parameter type is array Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2605) JS minimizer regression bug in 5.5.0-beta-1 Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2803) Add support for JavaScript/ECMAScript 6 modules Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2563) Session Replication fails with NotSerializableException on Tapestry class Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2778) JUnit upgrade to support Eclipse 2023-09+ Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2782) ajax.coffee should support more options Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2788) Further changes to upgrade to Jakarta EE Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2806) Upgrade Antlr 3 to 4 Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2773) NullPointerException in 5.8.5 when in production mode and template extension points Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2795) Upgrade commons-lang dependency to 3.17.0 Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2793) Create a component for rendering recursive data Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2770) With multiple classloader mode on, ClassCastException when component and superclass both have @Import Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2798) Change selenium-java and selenium-leg-rc from api to testImplementation Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2796) Upgrade some more dependencies: TestNG, EasyMock, commons-codec, ANTLR, HSQLDB, snakeyaml Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2799) Thread Lockup when trying to read from a Session Object Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2777) Update the closure compiler for better support of modern JavaScript Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2790) Palette with option groups within the SelectModel does not work properly. Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2806) Upgrade Antlr 3 to 4 Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2805) Upgrade underscore.js to 1.36.7 ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2805) Upgrade underscore.js to 1.36.7 ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2806) Upgrade Antlr 3 to 4 ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/14 (tapestry-5) branch javax updated: TAP5-2806: beanmodel setup junit, add ProperyConduitSpec thiagohp
• 2025/06/13 svn commit: r1090394 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/13 svn commit: r1090394 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/13 svn commit: r1090394 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/12 svn commit: r1090382 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/12 svn commit: r1090382 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/12 svn commit: r1090382 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/11 svn commit: r1090342 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/11 svn commit: r1090342 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/11 svn commit: r1090342 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/10 svn commit: r1090321 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/10 svn commit: r1090321 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/10 svn commit: r1090321 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/10 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/10 (tapestry-5) branch gradle-improvements updated (dd0a174b1 -> ebb298eea) benw
• 2025/06/09 (tapestry-5) 01/02: TAP5-2809: Fix Javadoc errors benw
• 2025/06/09 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/09 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/09 (tapestry-5) 02/02: TAP5-2809: Fix Javadoc warnings benw
• 2025/06/09 svn commit: r1090304 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/09 svn commit: r1090304 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/09 svn commit: r1090304 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/09 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/09 (tapestry-5) branch gradle-improvements created (now d7bd5f2a4) benw
• 2025/06/09 [jira] [Assigned] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup Ben Weidig (Jira)
• 2025/06/09 [jira] [Created] (TAP5-2809) Improve/Fix Gradle Setup Ben Weidig (Jira)
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: Fixing broken tests thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/08 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 01/02: TAP5-2804: adding test suites for Require.js enabled and not thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 02/02: Disabling tests with Require.js disabled while it's been worked thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated (7540860b8 -> 3108833af) thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript Hudson (Jira)
• 2025/06/08 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 10/14: Revert "Changing logging to stdout" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 08/14: Revert "More temporary logging" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 13/14: TAP5-2804: renaming Require.js-enabling configuration symbol thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 12/14: Revert "Testing logging in Jenkins builds" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 11/14: Revert "Enabling logging to Gradle console on tapestry-beanvalidator" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 07/14: Revert "More test logging (attempt 2)" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 05/14: Revert "More test logging (attempt 4)" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 09/14: Revert "Temporary changes to figure out failing tests on Jenkins" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 04/14: Revert "More test logging (attempt 5)" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 01/14: Revert "More test logging (attempt 8)" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 02/14: Revert "More test logging (attempt 7)" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 14/14: Trying to speed up integration tests thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 06/14: Revert "More test logging (attempt 3)" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) 03/14: Revert "More test logging (attempt 6)" thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated (69a29ab60 -> 7540860b8) thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 [jira] [Commented] (TAP5-2804) Convert Tapestry's JS code from CoffeeScript to TypeScript ASF subversion and git services (Jira)
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: TAP5-2804: task tapestry-core:compileTypeScript not being called thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 svn commit: r1090293 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/08 svn commit: r1090293 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/08 svn commit: r1090293 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: More test logging (attempt 8) thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: More test logging (attempt 6) thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: More test logging (attempt 7) thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: More test logging (attempt 5) thiagohp
• 2025/06/08 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: More test logging (attempt 4) thiagohp
• 2025/06/07 svn commit: r1090285 [1/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/07 svn commit: r1090285 [3/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/07 svn commit: r1090285 [2/3] - /websites/production/tapestry/content/ buildbot
• 2025/06/07 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: More test logging (attempt 3) thiagohp
• 2025/06/07 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: More test logging (attempt 2) thiagohp
• 2025/06/07 (tapestry-5) branch feature/coffeescript-to-typescript updated: More temporary logging thiagohp

• Earlier messages