From: Joan Lledó <[email protected]>
To: "Roy Marples"<[email protected]>
Cc: "bug-hurd"<[email protected]>
Date: Sat, 13 Jun 2026 12:24:45 +0100
Subject: Re: Guidance to implement io_select on network devices
 > I finally had some time today to actually get hands-on with the code and 
 > test everything. It works for me. 

Yay :)

 >  
 > The pfinet hook might need some changes to detect active translators 
 > instead of passive translators, and to not be strict about translators 
 > being installed at `/hurd/*`.

We can add some platform specific things easily if different from Debian or 
Gentoo.

 >  
 > On the other hand, pfinet and lwip react differently to fsysopts 
 > commands. I should make some changes to lwip to make it behave exactly 
 > like pfinet, for compatibility. There's no reason we should require a 
 > different hook for lwip. The pfinet one should be valid.

Yes. With my small play with lwip I could configure it with a hook like pfinet,
but inbound traffic didn't work and beyond DNS resolution and a simple ping,
outbound didn't work either. I did notice the MTU was 552 which is stupid small,
but anything bigger and nothing worked.
So I didn't add anything to the branch for it.
 
 >  
 > Also, of course, I'll work on the ethernet headers. 
 > 

Great!

Thanks

Roy


Reply via email to