Follow-up Comment #2, bug #38092 (project findutils):
I didn't find an option called --process-slot-var in the man or info page of
my xargs, is it the same as --max-procs or -P? If yes then those are not
sufficient because in MPI multiple copies of the same program are launched,
one per shared memory node, with identical command line arguments and
environment.
So for example if I were to have a list of files to process:
for i in $(seq 1 1 1000); do echo file"$i"; done > files
I can easily parallelize their processing on one node by calling xargs (in
many environments mpirun or its equivalent must be used to launch any program
on the compute nodes):
mpirun -n 1 xargs --args-file files -P 12 -n 5
But trying to use more than one node doesn't work because the same xargs is
invoked on each node meaning that each copy of xargs processes all of the
files. I.e.:
mpirun -n 1 xargs --arg-file files -P 12 -n 5 | wc -l
200
mpirun -n 2 xargs --arg-file files -P 12 -n 5 | wc -l
400
mpirun -n 3 xargs --arg-file files -P 12 -n 5 | wc -l
600
...
mpirun -n 10 xargs --arg-file files -P 12 -n 5 | wc -l
2000
It would be nice if in the above case when n copies of xargs are started by
MPI the file list would first be divided into n parts and then each of those
would be processed by only one xargs in the usual way. In principle adding
support for that should be easy but I didn't get very far in the few hours
that I hacked on xargs.c.
For a simple programs the modifications would consist of something like this:
At the top:
#ifdef HAVE_MPI
#include <mpi.h>
#endif
Then inside main:
#ifdef MPI_VERSION
int comm_size, rank;
MPI_Initialize(argc, argv);
MPI_Comm_rank(MPI_COMM_WORLD, &rank);
MPI_Comm_size(MPI_COMM_WORLD, &size);
// optionally check the return value of each MPI_* call...
#endif
Then in the place where the arguments are processed only process for example
every comm_sizeth arg starting at offset rank:
#ifdef MPI_VERSION
size_t current_arg = 0;
#endif
in the while loop (or for loop doing bc_push_arg?):
#ifdef MPI_VERSION
if (current_arg % size == rank) {
current_arg++;
#endif
...do the usual stuff here...
#ifdef MPI_VERSION
} else {
...maybe do something here just to skip this argument?...
}
#endif
and just before returning from main:
original_exit_value = child_error;
MPI_Finalize();
return child_error;
If not using MPI then the preprocessed source should stay identical to the
current version so these changes shouldn't be too invasive.
_______________________________________________________
Reply to this item at:
<http://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?38092>
_______________________________________________
Message sent via/by Savannah
http://savannah.gnu.org/
