Hi, I hit a segmentation fault with the array PROMPT_COMMAND. Here is
the report and a patch. There is also another trivial patch.
Configuration Information [Automatically generated, do not change]:
Machine: x86_64
OS: linux-gnu
Compiler: gcc
Compilation CFLAGS: -march=native -O3
uname output: Linux chatoyancy 5.6.13-100.fc30.x86_64 #1 SMP Fri May
15 00:36:06 UTC 2020 x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux
Machine Type: x86_64-pc-linux-gnu
Bash Version: 5.1
Patch Level: 0
Release Status: release
Description:
In the devel branch (e4d38c2d: commit bash-20200819 snapshot), a
segmentation fault occurs when a prompt command stored in the array
version of PROMPT_COMMAND unsets the corresponding element in
PROMPT_COMMAND.
The same happens for Bash 5.1-alpha with PROMPT_COMMANDS.
This is caused because the original array element data is free'd in
the evaluation process of the command string. The array scan and
the copy of all the command strings in PROMPT_COMMAND need to be
finished before executing the command strings.
Repeat-By:
For devel branch (PROMPT_COMMAND),
$ cat test19-devel.bashrc
my-prompt-command() { unset 'PROMPT_COMMAND[0]'; }
PROMPT_COMMAND=(my-prompt-command)
$ bash-dev --rcfile test19-devel.bashrc
Segmentation fault (core dumped)
For 5.1-alpha (PROMPT_COMMANDS),
$ cat test19-5.1.bashrc
my-prompt-command() { unset 'PROMPT_COMMANDS[0]'; }
PROMPT_COMMANDS=(my-prompt-command)
$ bash-5.1-alpha --rcfile test19-5.1.bashrc
Segmentation fault (core dumped)
As a related behavior, when one of the prompt commands assigns new
elements to the array PROMPT_COMMAND, the subsequent prompt commands
will not be executed. With the devel branch,
$ cat test19b.bashrc
function unregister-prompt_command {
local -a new=() cmd
for cmd in "${PROMPT_COMMAND[@]}"; do
[[ $cmd != "$1" ]] && new+=("$cmd")
done
PROMPT_COMMAND=("${new[@]}")
}
function my-prompt_command {
echo "$FUNCNAME"
# remove itself from PROMPT_COMMAND
unregister-prompt_command "$FUNCNAME"
}
PROMPT_COMMAND+=('echo test1')
PROMPT_COMMAND+=(my-prompt_command)
PROMPT_COMMAND+=('echo test2')
$ bash-dev --rcfile test19b.bashrc
test1
my-prompt_command # <-- test2 is expected but missing
bash-dev$
test1
test2 # <-- test2 is correctly called for the
bash-dev$ # next execution of PROMPT_COMMAND
Fix:
There is no problem with the scalar PROMPT_COMMAND. For the scalar
PROMPT_COMMAND, it uses the function `execute_variable_command'
(parse.y) which first copies the command string using
`savestring(cmd)' and pass it to `parse_and_execute'. This process
can be illustrated in the following schematic code.
{
Copy the value of PROMPT_COMMAND;
Execute the copy; /* this can modify the original variable */
Free the copy;
}
In this way, it doesn't cause problems even when the variable
PROMPT_COMMAND is rewritten in the processing of the command string
because the executed string is a copy of the original
PROMPT_COMMAND.
In the case of the array PROMPT_COMMAND, it uses the utility
`execute_variable_command' for each element, so the schematic code
would be:
for (PROMPT_COMMAND array_elements)
{
Copy the element;
Execute the copy; /* this can modify the array */
Free the copy;
}
This is robust for the case that the executed command modifies just
the string of the corresponding element, but vulnerable for the case
that the array structure is changed. This should be modified in the
following way:
{
Copy all the elements of PROMPT_COMMAND.
for (copied strings)
Execute the command strings.
Free the copied strings.
}
In the patch
`0001-Fix-a-segmentation-fault-of-array-PROPMT_COMMAND.patch', I
have added a function `execute_array_command' which is the array
version of `execute_variable_command'.
----
By the way, I suspect there is a memory leak in `bashline.c'.
bashline.c:4343: r = parse_and_execute (savestring (cmd),
"bash_execute_unix_command", SEVAL_NOHIST|SEVAL_NOFREE);
It appears to me that SEVAL_NOFREE shouldn't be specified here [see
the patch `0002-Fix-memleak-in-bash_execute_unix_command.patch'], or
otherwise, the string allocated by `savestring' will not be free'd.
In fact, I can observe that the memory use of the process is
monotonically increasing with the following operation:
$ bash --norc
$ arr=({1..100000})
$ bind -x "\"\C-t\":: '${arr[*]}"
(hit C-t many times)
Actually I have sent a related patch two years ago at
https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/bug-bash/2018-05/msg00020.html
In the patch at that time, I added `savestring' and removed
`SEVAL_NOFREE' as well.
- r = parse_and_execute (cmd, "bash_execute_unix_command",
SEVAL_NOHIST|SEVAL_NOFREE);
+ r = parse_and_execute (savestring (cmd),
"bash_execute_unix_command", SEVAL_NOHIST);
However, it seems that only the change to `savestring' was picked up
at that time, and the change of SEVAL_NOFREE was dropped in applying
the patch to the devel branch.
--- dfc21851b commit bash-20090723 snapshot
+++ 96b7e2687 commit bash-20180504 snapshot
- r = parse_and_execute (cmd, "bash_execute_unix_command",
SEVAL_NOHIST|SEVAL_NOFREE);
+ r = parse_and_execute (savestring (cmd),
"bash_execute_unix_command", SEVAL_NOHIST|SEVAL_NOFREE);
--
Koichi
