On Fri, Jun 06, 2008 at 10:38:41AM +0200, Andreas Schwab wrote:
> Stephane Chazelas <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:
>
> > The behavior is the same in ksh, but in ksh ${@:0:1} expands to
> > $0 which makes it more understandable ($0 has its meaning in
> > functions as well in ksh which makes it somehow consistent).
> >
> > In bash, ${@:0:1} and ${@:1:1} expand to the same thing ($1). Is
> > all that documented (I couldn't find it via a quick scan of the
> > man page)?
>
> $@ expands to the positional parameters, which $0 is not (it is a
> special parameter). Since index 0 does not exist, $1 is the first
> counted parameter in the expansion.
[...]
You make me remember that I had forgotten that aspect of ksh and
bash arrays in that they are associative arrays (contrary to
zsh's) with keys being only positive of null integers.
${a[0]} is the element of key 0. [EMAIL PROTECTED]:0:1} is the first
element of the list of $a elements numerically sorted by their
keys. And [EMAIL PROTECTED]:1:1} is the second element.
It still doesn't explain why ${@:1:1} expands to $1 and not $2
(if we assume that $0 is not part of $@ which I agree).
--
Stéphane
