I want to maintain the package. motivewave-latest-bin was supposed to be deleted yesterday.
If that package is removed then motivewave wouldn’t have any conflicting packages. motivewave has motivewave-latest-bin listed as conflicts (which is accurate) And motivewave-latest-bin has motivewave listed as conflicts (which is accurate) So today Xiota accused me of incompetence, motivewave indeed conflicts with motivewave-latest-bin. Not following Xiota commands step by step does not make me incompetent. Xiota claims the motivewave-latest-bin package will be deleted, but only after I remove motivewave-latest-bin as a conflict. I wonder what’s the interest in me removing motivewave-latest-bin first, and why does he even cares about that. According to https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/PKGBUILD#conflicts These packages are in conflict. They have the exact same source. On Mon, Sep 4, 2023 at 3:29 PM Aaron Liu <aaronliu0...@gmail.com> wrote: > I don't see why you're that infuriated. xiota is indeed a bit combative > with language but save for removing `conflicts` their suggestions all look > good. Simply adding the "no same owner" removes the need for all that find > chmod and chown stuff and just put the conflicting packing name under > "conflicts", no need to make a new variable. > > You can't accuse a suggestion of being wrong if you don't implement it > completely and you already did implement the dynamic URL in the pkgbuild > right; why are you still suggesting that implementing it breaks the > package? It already works albeit suboptimally because the no-same-owner > stuff hasn't been implemented. > > You do not have to maintain this package. Nobody is forcing you to go back > from church or a funeral. Your email seems like you're nitpicking their > admittingly combative language, and I don't see any nitpicks in the > line-by-line review. "Code review" has no negative connotations. > On 2023/9/4 15:20, Xavier Baez wrote: > > The variable they recommended was build_id > but that didn't create a clean > > makepkg --printsrcinfo > .SRCINFO > > Here are some of the comments, it's like > > https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/motivewave#comment-932313 > https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/motivewave#comment-932245 > https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/motivewave#comment-932340 > https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/motivewave#comment-932245 > https://aur.archlinux.org/packages/motivewave#comment-932340 > > Xiota also manages chaotic AUR, so he created an 'issue' where two > packages wouldn't be able to exist, so he deleted motivewave and created > motivewave-latest-bin > > Then I got re-uploaded, and within hours he re-deleted me again. > He also blocked me from their Git. > > Then he moved again to AUR motivewave to team up and the comments started > again. > > I would like to know what the rules are, today at Labor Day 3 AM the > change requests arrive again, yesterday I had to leave church to come home > and do more changes Test the package, was working. > I don't want to be forced to use variables or have a permanent code > reviewer. > Be called incompetent or imply I am dumb and need help. > > This is in the git and shows how their suggestions actually broke the > package. > I created my custom variable > > but the nit picking has not continued. > > Calling a person non competent, rude, rude, rude. > Especially when today the issue has been resolved. > > Here is how the package broke because code review. > > commit 1bceb28d1875deb4a303e6f13ee51e1ea86c0011 > Author: Xavier Baez <xavierb...@gmail.com> > Date: Sun Sep 3 09:12:02 2023 -0700 > > changes suggested by muflone > > When .SRCINFO is automatically generated with makepkg > > the following changes happen in SRCINFO > - source = motivewave-6.7.10.deb:: > https://downloads.motivewave.com/builds/500/motivewave_.deb > + source = motivewave-6.7.10.deb:: > https://downloads.motivewave.com/builds/{}/motivewave{6.7.10}_amd64.deb > > diff --git a/.SRCINFO b/.SRCINFO > index e82622d..1dd9db6 100644 > --- a/.SRCINFO > +++ b/.SRCINFO > @@ -1,7 +1,7 @@ > pkgbase = motivewave > pkgdesc = Advanced trading and charting application. > pkgver = 6.7.10 > - pkgrel = 3 > + pkgrel = 4 > url = https://www.motivewave.com > arch = x86_64 > license = custom > @@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ pkgbase = motivewave > depends = xorg-xrandr > provides = motivewave > conflicts = motivewave-latest-bin > - source = motivewave-6.7.10.deb:: > https://downloads.motivewave.com/builds/500/motivewave_.deb > + source = motivewave-6.7.10.deb:: > https://downloads.motivewave.com/builds/{}/motivewave{6.7.10}_amd64.deb > sha512sums = > c97e3bb78236d6ef1ae8581e29b128e6ee512f8241617dbcab5989f3068bfa6bbe9b9c091bb09b238ea891f59e6c12ef13ceee079610f3fc95722c58c4769bb9 > > > -- > Regards > > Xavier > > >
