grat args 2, really just replying to jason tho: - About 2577: But there is no explicit limit to what the 'modifications' can do. That's the scam. - About 2449: Regulated actions uses similar language - "A Regulated Action CAN only be performed as described by the Rules" - and yet I've proved in my previous grat args that regulated actions don't need to have their text entirely described in the Ruleset document itself. So neither should 'Winning the Game'.
On Mon, Sep 13, 2021 at 3:44 PM Jason Cobb via agora-business < [email protected]> wrote: > On 9/13/21 09:24, Cuddle Beam via agora-business wrote: > > I create the following contract called "Anime Powers": > > > > -+- > > An anime is an asset. It can be held by any person, and Cuddlebeam can > > create one in his ownership by announcement. Cuddlebeam is the > recordkeepor > > of animes. > > > > The following list are the modifications to the transferral of animes: > > - Animes CANNOT be transferred during the years 69, 420 or 8008135. > > - When some natural number amount of animes are transferred, Cuddlebeam > > wins the game of Agora nomic. > > - When a person attempts to transfer no animes, Cuddlebeam wins the game > of > > Agora nomic. > > -+- > > > > I create an anime in my ownership. > > I transfer one anime from myself to Peter Suber. > > I transfer no animes from myself to Peter Suber. > > > > > > I CFJ: In this message I have won the game. > > > Grat: > > Rule 2577/6 says "An asset generally CAN be transferred (syn. given) by > announcement by its owner to another entity, subject to modification by > its backing document. Attempts to transfer no assets are successful." > The authorization is only to transfer an asset; there's no rule-based > authorization to do anything else. The fact that the contract can place > restrictions on when the assets can be transferred does not mean that it > can co-opt the authorization into doing literally anything. > > > Also: > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > Rule 2449/3 (Power=3) > Winning the Game > > When the Rules state that a person or persons win the game, those > persons win the game; specifically they win the Round that ends > with the indicated win. Agora itself does not end and the ruleset > remains unchanged. The Herald is then authorized to award those > persons the Patent Title of Champion once, by announcement. > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > > > The rules have never stated that you win the game. You have a contract > that has stated that, but the rules themselves have never stated it. > > -- > Jason Cobb > > Assessor, Rulekeepor, Stonemason >
